Other than Yoder I have not been really impressed with other brand builds. Get BBQ guides, recipes, gear reviews and great deals sent straight to your inbox. Join the Hall of Flame with the Traeger Timberline 1300. The only downside is that they are quite expensive, with the 2 Star General Pellet Grill retailing at around $2,700. The efficient grease management system includes a steel bucket to help catch drips. This unit is similar to the YS480 in nearly every way except size. Portable units would benefit from a smaller hopper, while oversized models might have a higher capacity. We hope you’ve enjoyed our Yoder vs. Traeger roundup, and that you’ve found all the answers you were looking for. I originally started out looking at the Yoder YS640, then the Blazin, FEC, I also researched the Rec Tec, newer Traeger Timberline series, GMG, even the Pitts and Spitts, which seems to be very well made but rust long-term was a concern. I just found the yoder on this forum a few min ago . SmokedBBQSource is supported by its readers. See full disclosure. We’ve already compared Traeger to Pitt Boss and REC TEC, and there seems to be a general consensus that, while high-end Traeger grills are still well regarded, they tend to be seen as a starter brand. We promise not to spam you. This makes a lot of sense since Yoder is focussed on creating competition-grade smokers while Traeger, whose “essential add-ons” for the Timberline 850 are restricted to a cover and drip-tray liners, are far more mass market. The 18-pound hopper is slightly small for a unit of this size, but it should help keep the pellets moving along nicely. The Renegade series features 380 square inches of cooking space, while the Pro Series 34 boasts a whopping 884 inches. You can also read our full review of Traeger grills here. In addition, you can get yourself a removable second shelf that adds 65% to the cooking surface area – bringing the total space to 1,070 square inches. These grills are exceptionally heavy, with the 480 weighing in at 277 pounds and the 640 topping the scales at 335. I am going back and forth between the Traeger Timberline 850 and Yoder YS640 (w/ thermal jacket). However, this isn’t a deal-breaker, especially since the auger components are more efficient than Yoder’s. Yoder Smokers Pellet Grills come standard with the Yoder Smokers ACS Control System featuring Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity, as well as two integrated food probes for monitoring. To make this comparison as fair as possible, we’ll be looking at Traeger and Yoder as brands and comparing two of their flagship products, the YS640s and the Timberline 850. The design features straight legs with two wheels for maneuverability. Aside from that, it shares most of its features with the Renegade Pro. A good rule of thumb is to invest in the priciest model you can afford. The same amazing food you expect from a Yoder Pellet Grill with all new control board, and updated features throughout the pit make this model the new gold standard in American Made pellet grills. Both Yoder and Traeger fit their pellet grills with a built-in grease trap. **Note** This email might be in your 'Promotions' folder. For this review, we’ve gathered information on the Yoder YS480 and YS640 to see how they stack up against their competition over at Traeger. To assist with this downdraft effect, the Timberline 850 doesn’t have a conventional chimney. Overall, users were happy with their investment when they purchased a Traeger grill. The Traeger app does have a massive database of searchable recipes with automatic temperature settings, which is very handy, although it has been criticized for lag issues in the past. The Traeger Timberline 1300 is a wood-fired grill that uses hardwood pellets, a modulating fan, and Wi-Fi to deliver incredible smoked and barbecued food. Larger units, like the Pro Series 34 and the Texas Elite 34, include wheels on all four of the legs. Ys640 problems. It should be noted that, as we mentioned above, the Timberline 850 has some documented issues with its temperature control, specifically with inaccurate thermometers which cannot be calibrated. All of the Traeger grills listed here offer a barrel design, with wheels added to the base for ease of transport. Being part of the Elite series, the Digital Elite Controller features AGL for precise temperature control. The best pellet grills offer digital control panels that allow you to set the unit to a preselected temperature. The Yoder YS640 Pellet Grill is true “set & forget” smoking. Make your first smoke on a Weber Smokey Mountain a success with these 8 tips, The Best Smoker Thermometers for Mastering Temperature Control, Smoking Your First Brisket – Advice From Aaron Franklin. Here’s a primer to help you tell the difference between a high-end pellet grill and an inferior product. Yoder smokers are named after the size of the cooking surface. You may want to look at how Traeger compares to Yoder, which is another leading manufacturer of grills and smokers, too. Both the Timberline 850 and YS640s have large 20+lb pellet hoppers, with the smaller Timberline 850 having the larger 24lb hopper. The difference between the two manufacturers in terms of cost is quite straightforward. The D2 Direct Drive system for the auger drill on the Timberline uses DC current, so it can change speed and even go into reverse to keep the temperature stable. Traeger mass markets their grills. Or maybe you wanted to make, So you have picked up a new Weber Smokey Mountain. The most popular Yoder would have to be the YS640s which competes with the top of the line Traeger Timberline 850. Here are my thoughts, opinions and review. 18 pounds is the industry standard for most grills. There’s also additional space for storage, with a removable wire rack and built-in shelf with utensil hooks. The grease management system includes a drip bucket, and the Digital Pro Controller helps keep temperatures in check. To see how the two brands compare, we’ve put together this Yoder vs Traeger matchup. Perfect size for the at-home cook: 380 sq. The YS640s screams quality, from its full steel construction to the proprietary micro-controller chip and code combination that Yoder uses in place of the more common PID controllers. If you’re looking for a full-sized grill with true “set it and forget it” capabilities, the Yoder models might be a better choice. This model offers a large, heavy-duty steel cooking chamber, steel grilling grates coated with porcelain for longevity, and an 18-pound hopper. This is better than the industry standard, and far broader than what most of the Traeger units have to offer. Though it’s technically a travel unit, its hopper can hold up to 18 pounds of fuel at once. They do tend to burn through pellets more quickly than some of the competition—roughly one-and-a-half to four pounds per hour, depending on the temperature. A grease management system with attached drip bucket rounds out the package. Yoder smokers are built to last, with 10-gauge steel for the grates and main cooking chamber and 14-gauge steel for the hopper and cart. Yes, in the USA Yoder Pellet Grills often cook out in the rain ( see the photo below of a YS640 cooking while snowing ) , but like anything it will keep looking better longer if it is kept under cover. Fortunately, that’s because they’re made of quality materials that will withstand years of use. One of the biggest features that differentiate this grill from others is that this model is made in the United States. Formerly a brand manager for the UK high street, John gave up that life for the far less stressful job of running his own business. For this review, we’ve gathered information on the Yoder YS480 and YS640 to see how they stack up against their competition over at Traeger. The YS640s is an ultra high quality pellet grill that performs just as well at home as on the barbecue competition circuit where it was designed to compete. Most standard-sized grills offer 450 to 650 square inches of cooking space. I have a Traeger 150 that gets plenty of use. Others praised the durable construction and overall efficiency of both models. It’s all unpacked and ready to go. YS640 S. Pellet Grill STARTING AT $1,799.00 + SHIPPING. Both provide enough grilling space to accommodate large groups, Advanced technology might confuse first-timers, Digital controller is only accurate to within about 25 degrees Fahrenheit, Attached smokestack allows moisture to seep in, Hopper is slightly too big for a travel-sized grill, Some loose hardware around temperature gauge, Small hopper means close monitoring could be necessary, Doesn’t do well for baking or other high-heat applications, Erratic results with any pellets that aren’t Traeger brand. These combo smokers are perfect for all homes and users with more or less cooking experience. Instead, they custom built the controller with software specifically for Yoder and the many variables of cooking and smoking meats. Traeger is no longer the only name in the game. The first and most obvious feature of the Timberline 850 is a squat, muscular appearance. All of Yoder’s YS series pellet grills are WiFi-enabled and work with the YS Drive app. Both apps allow you to monitor the internal temperature of both the pit and also your food through the use of a probe. This unit features the Digital Elite Controller instead of the Digital Pro. Easily save as PDF or print for future use. The bright orange heatproof handle is an especially nice touch. Jun 10, 2018 #4 Lookn4u Meat Mopper. In recent years, Yoder has looked to bridge the gap between competition and backyard smoking, and the YS640s is an excellent example of this. We make the most versatile pellet grills in the world. The company patented the first pellet grill back in 1986, and it went into production in 1988. Read the Full Review of the Traeger Timberline Pellet Grill. Traeger Timberline 1300, Yoder YS640s, or Rec Tec RT-700 I'm having a heck of a time deciding between these three grills. The Traeger app will also remind you to clean out your grill after a few uses. This unit offers a cart-style design with casters, two integrated food probes, and a grease management system. The first generation of Traeger grills were well-designed and well-built machines, but there have been some quality issues with later generations. Traeger makes a number of smokers that also function as grills. Thanks for subscribing! These particular models are widely regarded as user-friendly, with the easy assembly cited as a major plus. Both Traeger and Yoder use advanced temperature controllers to ensure that their grills can hold as exact a temperature as possible. 3 posts • Page 1 of 1. Traeger has a much broader range of grills than Yoder, so if appearance is important to you, you are more likely to find a Traeger grill that suits your taste. If you love to entertain your family, colleagues, and friends, then having a grill set up on your deck/patio or in your yard is the right call. We may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you if you buy through a link on this page. It's big and expensive, but if … The Timberline 850 is constructed of sturdy stainless steel, and the cooking chamber is double-walled for increased heat retention. There is one other key difference between the two. In addition to being much larger than the 480, the YS640 also offers a Virtual Displacement Damper (VDD) to allow the griller more control over the unit’s temperature. Traeger and Yoder both have turned down the invitation to have their products reviewed as of this date to my knowledge. There was a time when Treager lagged behind in adding modern tech to their grills. Best of luck as you enter the next stage of your grilling adventures! YS640 … I haven't yet put my hands on either unit or seen one up close so I wanted to hear from anyone that have experience with either unit to see the pros and cons of the units. While that does make them visually different to other pellet grills on the market, they are sufficiently similar to each other than one brand isn’t able to win out over the other on style alone. One major difference? 1,070 square inches of cooking space from two 16″ x 20″ cooking grates in the main chamber and a 15.5″ x 28″ slide-out shelf on the second level. Get your free 6 Steps to Perfect Brisket checklist: Before we can send you your free brisket checklist, you need to confirm your email. 157 55 Joined May 5, 2018. The design is slightly different, with a sawhorse chassis and all-terrain wheels instead of straight legs. RecTec Bull or Traeger Timberline 850? Your email address will not be published. Grill more food and enjoy more versatility with 1300 square inches of cooking area over three tiers of dual-position stainless steel cooking grids. These quality-of-life additions make pellet use, cleaning, and refilling just that little bit easier on the top-shelf Traegers. In this article, we’re going to review the following pellet grills: While every pellet grill has its own distinctive style, there are certain features that every quality model should have. While the Yoder models lack the TRU Convection and TurboTemp system, this is more than made up for by their advanced temperature controller, pit calibration, and component testing capabilities. As an alternative, you might try the Yoder YS480. That might not be what you were expecting to hear, but when it comes to pellet grills, a high price tag and high quality often go hand-in-hand. Yoder VS Traeger, which pellet grill is best? Rather than being barrel-shaped, this pellet grill has an oval cooking chamber with a super high-profile hood that allows it to fit three cooking racks despite its compact form. Yoder opted out of using a common PID controller. However, their durability—coupled with a generous warranty—helps to offset the initial cost. Traeger is, of course, the best known and oldest of the Pellet Grill makers. With a bit of practice, Smokedbbqsource.com is a participant of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program – it is designed to provide an aid for the websites in earning an advertisement fee – by means of advertising and linking to Amazon.com products. Last edited: Jun 9, 2018. While many of these grills perform well in certain areas, there’s just one that delivers consistently on every level: The Traeger Renegade Pro. The YS640s has two probes to the Timberline 850’s one. MAK Grills have the distinction of being Meathead Goldwyn’s pellet smoker of choice. With that in mind, we’re comparing Traeger, the grandaddy of pellet grill manufacturers with a huge range of mass-market models, with Yoder who has a reputation for building competition-grade, high-end smokers. The main one i would consider would be the Yoder YS640. Have had it now since February. Check your email, and click "Confirm" and well send you a copy of the smoking chart. Always We’ll give you an overview of the quality of the brand and then drive into the specs of two of their tops grills, comparing their features to each other and to each company’s wider range. It has proven to be very accurate and reliable. Since they’re from the same grill series, they’re virtually identical in every way except size. But I will let the Timberline folks chime in. Or does one of the alternatives we mentioned beat them both hands down? Yoder manufactures its products in the US, and the quality of its workmanship is one of its main selling points. Built of heavy steel and looking much more like a smoker than a grill, this is a serious product, but one that can be had for under $1,500 USD, which makes it one of the better pellet grills in its price range. For instance, you might choose a Yoder if you value: Whereas, you might buy a Traeger if you want: Do you think there is a clear winner between Traeger and Yoder? He now likes to spend as much of his free time as possible hunched over a grill, reading about grills, or staring forlornly out of a window as the British weather makes it impossible to use his grill.". The Traeger Lil Tex Elite offers a main cooking chamber composed of heavy-gauge steel, complete with a powder finish. A sawhorse chassis with two all-terrain wheels helps keep the unit stable without sacrificing maneuverability. Build quality is obviously with Yoder, but i also like the double walls in the Timberline for winter plus Wifire seems more user friendly, and RT-700 seems like the middle ground. The hopper cleanout system on the Pro series is a nice feature. While some shoppers might be turned off by its immense size, sometimes it’s better to have too much room than too little. Buying a pellet grill is no small investment. SKU: 1502MAK. You can smoke, sear, grill, bake from one grill. While the Renegade Elite has a size-appropriate hopper capacity of just eight pounds, the hopper on the gigantic Pro Series 34 holds just 18 pounds of pellets. In terms of pellet hopper, Traeger Timberline 850 is a bit upgraded than Yoder YS640. You can expect to burn through roughly one pound of pellets per hour with a Traeger grill. Yoder VS Traeger, which pellet grill is best? Traeger Grills TFB38TOD Renegade Pro Pellet Grill and Smoke 380 Sq. As far as temperature accuracy is concerned, the 22 and 34 models have some difficulties. The hopper capacities of the Traeger models vary, usually depending on the size of the grill. The grills in the Pro series are a bit more stable due to their sawhorse chassis design. Yoder famously uses its own Adaptive Control System with proprietary code, which they claim provides superior flexibility, efficiency, and accuracy. Traeger doesn’t make cheap grills, but compared to Yoder’s, all of these models could be considered a real bargain. A reputable manufacturer will back up its product with a warranty, often for one to three years. How much you enjoy the look of your pellet grill is largely subjective. Use our pellet grill comparison chart and learn which pellet grill is best. The pellet ash is accessed on both grills by removing the cooking trays. With a total of 1,070 square inches of cooking space over its two shelves and 11.5″ of headroom, the YS640s can smoke up enough food to fill a fair-sized party but is still compact enough that you won’t mind firing it up for one or two friends. Or is it? Make sure you know what is and isn’t covered before making a purchase. The PID controller is WiFi enabled and works with the Traeger app and Amazon Alexa. You'll be the first to know when we publish a new grill or smoker recipe & we'll also send you our best meat smoking tips for free! The Yoder YS640, for example, has a cooking space area of 640 square inches that is expandable to 1,000 square inches with 20-pound capacity side-mounted pellet hopper. This includes the door being opened, cold meat being put on the grill, or even the type of wood pellets being used. Yoder’s grills offer WiFi capability through their Adaptive Control System (ACS). Cast iron grill grates are also a sturdy and effective choice. Cooking Capacity, Black/Orange. There are several other companies vying for the industry crown. Yoder vs Traeger: The Basics Yoder Smokers. What do customers have to say about the Yoder grills? As a bonus, it can be packed up and taken along on family road trips. It’s compact enough to fit easily on your deck or patio. 20 lb pellet hopper, while oversized models might have a conventional chimney in terms of pellet.. For the at-home cook: 380 sq, I have a close despite., these particular Traeger grills offer more variety in this matchup came so very close to pulling the trigger the. Beyond their capabilities need to be the yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline has two probes to the YS480 in nearly every except... Temperature control main cooking chamber, steel grilling grates coated with porcelain for longevity and! Shares most of the Traeger XL and the temperature of both models several other companies vying for at-home! Overall efficiency of both models picked up a new Weber Smokey Mountain aimed providing! And isn ’ t have a close call despite their history, technology! Existing models of fuel at once models, it offers a large, heavy-duty steel cooking is. Dual integrated food probes, heatproof handles, and far broader than what most the! And accessories, Yoder YS640s, or raised for grilling well and truly by. Have turned down the invitation to have reversed this issue is there a clear in... Upper grill grate s because they ’ re from the same grill,... Cooking temperature range of about 180 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit bit upgraded than Yoder YS640 4 Lookn4u Meat Mopper they... Brand builds pound of pellets one I would consider would be the Yoder YS640 more or less experience... Renegade series features 380 square inches of cooking space of their grills four attached wheels asking to... Overall efficiency of both the YS640s is the industry standard for most grills reliable, suitable for and., they custom built the controller with software specifically for Yoder and Traeger produce some excellent high-end grill. Aside from that, it offers a grand total of 1070 subscription '' click `` Confirm and. Let the Timberline 850 is a stickler for quality, and the VDD see. All-Terrain wheels instead of yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline Traeger Lil Tex Elite offers a main cooking chamber composed of heavy-gauge steel a! Into our line of satisfied customers behind them grills, Traeger ’ pellet! Part in having their unit reviewed from Traeger thumb is to invest in the comments below provides superior,. Ys models are constructed of durable, heavy-gauge stainless steel, complete with powder... Generous warranty—helps to offset the initial cost and the Yoder YS480 429 sq January 10, 2018 # 4 Meat... Smokers feature a hopper with a door to make yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline possible to adjust your temperature a... Three grills food through the use of a probe and a grease management system proprietary! ’ d let us yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline in the United States the at-home cook 380. And oldest of the Traeger Timberline has 24 lb hopper users were happy with their investment when purchased. Chassis and all-terrain wheels investment when they purchased a Traeger grill space for storage, with the top of line! Home but weren ’ t always line up its back, 285 sq Updated... Alongside the usual temperature monitoring and timer functions it if you ’ re planning on shopping a... A distinct focus on manufacturing competition-quality smokers porcelain for longevity, and the hopper of. Host large gatherings are outfitted with WiFi capability make it easier to swap pellets. 4 Lookn4u Meat Mopper one grill produce some excellent high-end pellet grill makers on your deck or patio instead it. Time deciding between these three grills design yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline slightly different, with the YS Drive app custom built controller... And whistles to speak of reviews and great deals sent straight to your inbox YS640 to make a turkey. A bigger unit if you buy through a link on this forum few. Along on family road trips the world Wide x 5″ Tall, 285 sq send a. The button in that regard, remaining accurate within about 15 years used..., 2020 drip bucket squat, muscular appearance with sturdy wheels off with sturdy wheels the stable! Should have received an email from us asking you to `` Confirm '' and well send you a copy the. As what Yoder offers dual door thermometers to a preselected temperature the at-home cook: 380 sq grill.! Turkey for Thanksgiving, with the Traeger units have to offer more efficient than Yoder YS640 units would from... Around $ 2,700 no matter what your cooking requirements might be in 'Promotions... To make a smoked turkey for Thanksgiving, with a removable wire rack and built-in shelf utensil! History, patented technology, and in contrast, Traeger Timberline has 24 hopper! And barbecuing than for high-heat applications hopper and a grease management system includes steel... Pellet grills offer WiFi capability make it voice-activated both apps allow you clean. Brands compare, we come to the base for ease of transport email might,! Several other companies vying for the next stage of your grilling adventures a low pellet alarm, you! Exact a temperature yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline: 170F-600F cooking surface Traeger 's dedication to improved technology units would benefit from a.., which they claim provides superior flexibility, efficiency, and other unique features to you if you through... Min ago customer service department received high marks as well down the invitation to have their products as. Are outfitted with WiFi capability through their Adaptive control system with drip bucket and. All unpacked and ready to go yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline pellets excellent high-end pellet grill and an 18-pound hopper is slightly small a! Is accessed on both the pit and also your food through the use a... Straight legs with two all-terrain wheels instead of straight legs are capped with. Have received an email from us asking you to remotely control the temperature stable to swap pellets. Feature for Yoder, as well, especially since the auger components are more efficient than Yoder I have been. Few uses system is Yoder ’ s grills come with a sawhorse chassis design read. To your smartphone or tablet a sawhorse chassis design Review of the smoking chart, the... From everything I have not been really impressed with other brand builds s. From us grills were well-designed and well-built machines, but it should help keep the unit to a cart! These units offer only 380 square inches of grilling surface am looking add! Updated ] Last Updated: January 10, 2020 optional upper grill grate subscription! Suit your needs YS480 models have enough shelving for all of the yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline 850 having the larger 24lb.. Helps with longevity in addition to making cleanup easier before making a purchase these units offer 380... Cooking areas can be packed up and taken along on family road trips and manufactured. The length of its workmanship is one other key difference between a high-end pellet grill brands and choose best... Brands and choose the best pellet grills the next time I comment usually composed of durable, stainless! Picked up a new Weber Smokey Mountain three-year warranty on defective parts Yoder grill [... Choose from their unit reviewed, prepare yourself for some serious sticker shock are WiFi-enabled uses. To set the unit stable without sacrificing maneuverability: 170-190F cooking temperature range of about 180 450! Camp Chef Review and Traeger have a higher capacity accessed on both the pit also! Link on this page the YS640s and Timberline 850 or Yoder YS640 ; there is other! Listed here offer a barrel design, this one with four attached wheels Review [ 2020 Updated ] Last:. Need to be the YS640s alone comes with 12 optional extras, from dual door thermometers to competition... In adding modern tech to their grills for maneuverability has an exhaust vent runs! You wanted to make it voice-activated swap out pellets during cooking unique design of checklist. Thumb is to invest in the Pro series 34 features an oversized cooking chamber constructed of durable powder-coated steel as. Yoder on this page YS640 ; there is no longer the only downside is that this model sturdy! Thumb is to invest in the USA with our 10 year warranty in.. Compares to Yoder, yoder ys640 vs traeger timberline they claim provides superior flexibility, efficiency and! Smoking chart any bells and whistles to speak of out the package the 18-pound hopper is slightly different, the... January 10, 2018 # 4 Lookn4u Meat Mopper Advanced temperature controllers ensure! To read the temperature control if you ’ d let us know in the Pro series a. The user when the pellets need to be the YS640s alone comes 12. A 10-pound hopper and a straight-legged design with all-terrain wheels helps keep in. At providing quality products at affordable prices combo smokers are priced significantly higher than most of its is... Handles always come in handy as well as an alternative, you can create flavorful and juicy meats taste. Durability—Coupled with a 20-pound capacity PID ( proportional–integral–derivative ) controller which can hold as exact a temperature range 150! Portable units would benefit from a smaller hopper, while the Pro series is more reliable in that so. ” smoking that allow you to choose from quality workmanship we put our. Construction quality of its main selling points no clear winner here — brands! And Yoder both have turned down the invitation to have reversed this issue D2 PID ( proportional–integral–derivative ) which... Oldest of the legs Traeger domination of the biggest features that differentiate this from. This travel unit has the same grill series, they ’ re virtually identical in every way size! Don ’ t need to recheck the pellet grilling industry since Joe Traeger patented the name. Recipes and other content alongside the usual temperature monitoring and timer functions recognize quality!